CC Sabathia has been absolutely amazing since coming to the Brewers from the Indians, check out this stat line; 9-0, 1.43 ERA, .99 WHIP, 85 K’s in 11 starts with the Brewers. Truly amazing, and to top it all off he just needed to make history, with a no-hitter perhaps? He was robbed of one last night. By who you ask? An innocent scorekeeper.
CC Sabathia had already made a spectacular play earlier in the game to show his athleticism. A bare handed grab of a searing line drive by Freddy Sanchez and then doubled off Jack Wilson at first.
In the fifth inning however, Andy Laroche had a little swinging bunt a little to the left of the pitchers mound, CC Sabathia ran over grabbed the ball, bobbled it, then dropped it. The play was immediately ruled a hit, that was the only hit of the game for the Pirates.
After the game Brewers manager Ned Yost said it was a joke that the hit was ruled a hit and that it was clearly an error. To me it looked like an error, I mean Sabathia had already shown his ability to make great plays earlier, he bobbled the ball and didn’t make the play, that’s an error. If the shortstop had done that it would have been an error.
Milwaukee is appealing the call to the MLB. I think it should be reversed but it may cause a bigger issue if done so. Other teams will say they just reversed the call to give him a no-hitter and it will cause a whole big raucous, but if major league baseball is willing to use instant replay then they should look at the tapes and repeal the call. Even if that play was ruled an error you never know how Sabathia would have handled the pressure.